38 Years In Prison For Changing Grades?
Saturday, June 28th, 2008I’m sure none of my readers ever got bad grades in high school, but I received a few. Most of the time it was the result of being lazy. I just never got around to studying and the result was a bad grade.
I would guess most bad grades are the result of not studying. I suppose some are the result of not understanding the material. And, admit it, some are the result of being dumb.
I know, I know, it’s not “politically correct” to call anybody dumb. But face it, some people are. Like the two high school seniors from California I read about recently.
These guys apparently had it all. They lived in an affluent area, went to a modern, new high school, one was planning to study law in college, but they managed to make some bad grades. Now that doesn’t make them dumb. Oh no, you have to go above and beyond for me to call you dumb!
On April 20, one of the boys requested a copy of his official transcript. School administrators noticed that his “average” grades had become “excellent” grades. They suspected the grades had been tampered with and notified the sheriff’s department.
On the night of May 19, a school custodian saw two boys running from a darkened classroom. The next day one boy was arrested. The other boy turned himself in later.
The sheriff’s investigation reveled that the two had broken into the school on several occasions, installed spyware on school computers in order to capture passwords, and used the passwords to gain access to the computers and change their `C’, `D’, and `F’ grades to `A’ and “A-` grades. They also have been accused of stealing tests and sending the test answers to dozens of their friends.
According to an article in the New York Times, the charges against the two include identity theft, burglary and computer fraud. If convicted of all charges they face up to 38 years in prison.
One of the boys lawyers compared the crimes committed to those of Ferris Bueller, the character in a 1986 movie who hacks into his school’s attendance records. “Does this young man deserve to have his future ruined over this event? I think absolutely not.”
Changing grades could certainly be considered a prank, but breaking into the school? Installing spyware on the schools computers? Stealing passwords? These are crimes, and serious crimes at that.
Do they deserve 38 years in prison? Probably not, but the crimes can’t just be laughed off either. One freshman at the school “…likened the alleged crime to a `really cool’ James Bond mission. `Maybe they were just doing this to help their friends,’ he said.”
It seems to me that the way kids think these days, these two are probably already some sort of folk hero. If they aren’t punished, it would send a message to other students that, at least some of the time, crime does pay.
What do you think? Should these two be punished the same as someone who breaks into a school to steal something with a monetary value? Should they be punished like someone who hacks into a computer to steal money or government secrets? Should they be punished like someone who steals passwords in order to steal someone’s identity? Or should they be given a good talking to and allowed to continue their schooling with corrected grades?
